Monday, 5 November 2012

Red Squirrels V Buzzards: A Dilema ...

Hi everyone,


Ive just received an e-mail from BBC South, who are following up reports of buzzard attacks on red squirrels, here on the island. They are doing some research on this subject, with a view to a possible programme on this issue.

I myself have not heard of any attacks, nor seen any, but I guess that the way to investigate would be to inspect the nests of the buzzards to look for bones, fur, or remains of squirrels. I would imagine that the droppings/pellets would leave evidence too. I would imagine that only a licensed person would be able to do this, so a proper study seems to be the way forward.

Maybe more evidence needs to be gathered, a study made on the growing population of buzzards on the island vs the (declining?) numbers of red squirrels, would be a good start.
I for one, was totally against the cull of buzzards earlier this year, as were loads of people who signed my online petition. But the cull I beleive was only started by the hunting brigade who were against the buzzards, because of the losses in certain parts of the country of the young pheasants.
The buzzard is only doing what comes naturally of course.

Which brings us to the point, would it be right to have a partial cull of buzzard eggs to protect the red squirrels, if it was proven that these beautiful birds were seriously affecting the population of reds?
A tricky one!
A cull or partial cull to protect the red squirrels population on the island would be controversial, but I beleive if the issue of buzzards seriously affecting red squirrels, to the extent that they would become endangered then maybe this could be justified.

What does everyone think about this?
Have you seen or heard of any attacks?


 

4 comments:

  1. Hi Dave, I'm a local birder/recent convert. Like your pictures.
    Re:topic: I don't like the idea of intervening with nature on any level, although perhaps sometimes it's necessary if there is concrete evidence for an unbalance with a particular species. But it shouldn't be a decision taken lightly or with bias, I would say.
    There is a closed group on facebook (IOW birding) that's worth joining where you can talk about local birding etc. It's building up quite a few members. Gets my recommendation. JS.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi JS,
    I sent you an e-mail, hope you received it, if not let me know.
    Thanks for your views, have joined th fb group, very interesting!
    Cheers

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Dave. I live in Toronto, Canada and I nature should be allowed to run its course. Mind you when it comes to Grey squirrels, that is a different matter. Earlier this year, my wife, Jean, and I were in Ireland where we came upon the rarely seen Red Squirrel. They actually look somewhat like our Canadian Red Squirrels, but boy, do they have long ears! We were shocked to learn that your Red squirrels are contracting the pox virus from Grey Squirrels, and dying. So we feel very lucky to have seen able to see two Red Squirrels well visiting in Ireland. We have posted some of our pictures and video for anyone interested at: http://frametoframe.ca/photo-essay-red-grey-squirrels-canada-ireland

    ReplyDelete
  4. We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your web site offered us with valuable info to work on. You’ve done an impressive job and our entire community will be grateful to you.

    - Small Tar Sprayers | Floater cum Trowel Machine | Small Bitumen Sprayers

    ReplyDelete